BlackBerry maker loses patent case

Posted by on Jul 15, 2012 | Comments Off on BlackBerry maker loses patent case

A federal jury in San Francisco has found beleaguered BlackBerry maker Research in Motion Ltd liable for US$147.2m (€120.14m) in damages for infringing on patents held by Mformation Technologies.

Amar Thakur, a lawyer for Mformation, said that the verdict followed a three-week trial and a week of deliberations by an eight-person jury.

Mformation’s software allows companies to remotely access employee cell phones to do software upgrades, change passwords or to wipe data from phones that have been stolen.

Officials at RIM, which has been struggling with plummeting sales, a declining stock and other problems, did not provide a comment Saturday.

Mr Thakur said the jury ruled that Research in Motion should pay his client $8 (€6.52) for each of the 18.4 million BlackBerrys that were connected to the BlackBerry Enterprise Server, from the day the lawsuit was filed until the time of the trial. That is a total of $147.2m (€120.14m).

He said the software at issue is the heart of the business of Mformation, a privately held company with several hundred employees.

“We believe it’s been fundamental to the success of Research in Motion,” Mr Thakur said.

The patent at issue was filed in 2001 and issued in 2005, he said.

Particularly telling is the plunge in the BlackBerry’s US market share. It has dropped from 41% in 2007, the year the first iPhone came out, to below 4% in the first three months of this year, according to research firm IDC.

RIM, of Waterloo, Ontario, has previously denied it did anything wrong.

RIM has seen its business crumble as it increasingly loses market share. Today’s consumers want smartphones that go far beyond handling e-mail and phone calls, with built-in cameras and other cool functions.

Not only will devices with the new BlackBerry software miss the crucial holiday shopping season, they will have even more competition when they do go on sale, including a new iPhone expected from Apple this autumn.
Mformation, of Edison, New Jersey, sued Research in Motion in October 2008, alleging that Canada-based RIM infringed on its 1999 invention for remotely managing wireless devices.

Meanwhile, RIM will miss a chance to bounce back because of repeated delays on its BlackBerry 10 operating software, which is intended to help Blackberrys catch up to rivals such as the iPhone and smartphones running Google’s Android software.



You can subscribe by e-mail to receive news updates and breaking stories.